Mrs Plevin was sold a PPI policy to cover her secured Loan from Paragon Personal Finance Ltd. She took a Claim to the Supreme Court in November 2014, alleging that the contract and her relationship with Paragon was unfair due to:
- Non-disclosure of the commission
- The percentage of the PPI premium that was commission.
The Supreme Court ruled that failure by the Lender to disclose the large commissions payable out of Mrs Plevin’s PPI premiums created an unfair relationship between her and the Lender and full redress was awarded to Mrs Plevin. This case has been regarded as a precedent for other consumers seeking redress.